A gradual retreat into strategic passivity led to the world’s spinning suddenly out of control.
Suddenly, the Biden administration faces a massive and complicated crisis in the Middle East. Missiles and warplanes streak across the skies above Gaza. Saudi Arabia bitterly criticizes Israel’s response to the Hamas atrocities, and much of the Arab and Islamic world has exploded in rage against the Jewish state. Mobs rampage through the streets, and American diplomats take shelter amid protests outside U.S. embassies from Baghdad to Beirut. Iran threatens Israel with more attacks, and Hezbollah is keeping pressure on Israel’s northern border.
President Biden’s decision to fly to Israel showed energy and courage. But more is needed. As I wrote in my last column, Mr. Biden has yet to grapple with the painful truth that America’s core problem in the Middle East is the march of an unappeasable Iran toward regional power regardless of moral or human cost.
That is not the only thing Mr. Biden and his team don’t seem to have grasped. The Middle East firestorm is merely one hot spot in a world spinning out of control. The success of Hamas sent waves of excitement through jihadist groups and terror cells in Africa, Europe, the Middle East and beyond. Riots in France, a shooting in Belgium, anti-Semitic marches in Berlin and other uprisings across Europe point to a resurgence of radicalism. Africa, where feeble governments have lost the ability to control jihadist groups across swaths of territory, and where Russia’s Wagner Group supports many corrupt and violent military regimes, is bracing for more terror in more parts of the continent. The war on terror is plotting its comeback even as the Cold War between the U.S. and the revisionist powers heats up.
As Hamas put a torch to the Middle East, Russia’s Legislature revoked its ratification of the Comprehensive Nuclear Test Ban Treaty and ended limits on missile technology sales to Iran. Mysterious disruptions to a gas pipeline and telecommunications cables in the Baltic Sea continue.
Flying to Beijing, President Vladimir Putin toasted the growing friendship between Russia and China and celebrated a historic high in their bilateral trade. Trade between the two countries has roughly doubled since Mr. Putin’s original 2014 invasion of Ukraine.
Trade between Russia and North Korea also has flourished. National Security Council spokesman John Kirby said last week that North Korea has delivered more than 1,000 containers of military supplies and weapons to Russia. What does Pyongyang want in return? “Fighter aircraft, surface-to-air missiles, armored vehicles, ballistic-missile production equipment, or other materials and other advanced technologies,” Mr. Kirby said. With Russian Foreign Minister Sergei Lavrov currently visiting North Korea, he and his hosts will have plenty to talk about.
China is also getting frisky. In the past two years, there have been more than 180 documented cases of People’s Liberation Army planes harassing American aircraft, the Pentagon said this week. That exceeds the number of such incidents in the entire preceding decade. More ominously, China’s pressure on Taiwan continues to grow. The number of Chinese military aircraft flying sorties into Taiwan’s air defense identification zone rose from 380 in 2020 to more than 1,700 in 2022. China has also increased the number of fighter jets and bombers (including bombers capable of delivering nuclear weapons) venturing close to the island. On one day last month, more than 100 Chinese military aircraft flew missions near Taiwan, with 40 entering the air defense identification zone.
Why are so many actors challenging American power in so many parts of the world? Because the U.S. is losing its power to deter. Like Mike Campbell’s bankruptcy, the erosion of deterrence usually begins gradually and ends suddenly. Emboldened by American failures to respond effectively (as when Mr. Putin invaded Georgia in 2008 and Ukraine in 2014, when President Obama failed to enforce his “red line” in Syria, or when China built and militarized artificial islands in the South China Sea), our adversaries gradually lost their inhibitions and dared to challenge us more directly in more damaging ways.
Mr. Putin’s 2022 invasion of Ukraine in defiance of direct American warnings was a major step. Iran’s support for Hamas’s strike on Israel is an even bolder attack on the American order. If President Biden’s response to Hamas and its patron Iran fails to restore respect for American power, wisdom and will, our enemies everywhere will draw conclusions and take steps that we and our allies won’t like.
As Mr. Biden analyzes his options and the support he is prepared to offer Israel, he needs to remember that the world is watching. Strategic passivity as deterrence erodes is a recipe for escalating crises and, ultimately and sometimes quite suddenly, war.
Copyright ©2023 Dow Jones & Company, Inc. All Rights Reserved. 87990cbe856818d5eddac44c7b1cdeb8
Appeared in the October 20, 2023, print edition as ‘A World Without American Deterrence’.
https://www.wsj.com › Opinion › Global View
5 days ago — A World Without American Deterrence · A gradual retreat into strategic passivity led to the world’s spinning suddenly out of control. · What to …
A World without American Deterrence
https://www.hudson.org › defense-strategy › world-wi…
5 days ago — A World without American Deterrence. A gradual retreat into strategic passivity led to the world’s spinning suddenly out of control.
The Nukes We Need: Preserving the American Deterrent
https://www.jstor.org › stable
by KA Lieber · 2009 · Cited by 103 — If the only retaliatory option entails killing millions of civilians, then the U.S. deterrent will lack credibility. Giving. U.S. leaders alternatives that do …
Beyond Deterrence: U.S. Nuclear Statecraft Since 1945
American Academy of Arts and Sciences
https://www.amacad.org › publication › section
by FJ Gavin — Surrounded by two oceans, facing weak countries on its borders, and possessing command of the commons and overwhelming conventional, economic, and soft power …
“The War That Must Never Be Fought: Dilemmas of Nuclear …
https://www.brookings.edu › articles › the-war-that-…
In chapter three of The War That Must Never Be Fought: Dilemmas of Nuclear Deterrence, entitled “A Realist’s Rationale for a World without Nuclear Weapons,” …
America’s real deterrence problem
https://www.brookings.edu › articles › americas-real-…
Jun 15, 2022 — The United States‘ real deterrence problem is not an inadequacy of a willingness to threaten — and ultimately to use — military force, …
American Deterrence’s Missing Half
https://www.rand.org › blog › 2022/01 › american-det…
Jan 24, 2022 — If American deterrence fails, it may not be because adversaries doubt U.S. military capabilities so much as they doubt American willpower.
Toward a World without Nuclear Weapons
https://media.nti.org › pdfs › NSP_op-eds_final_
Nuclear weapons were essential to main- taining international security during the Cold. War because they were a means of deterrence. The end of the Cold War …
24 pages
Robert Gates: Can a Divided America Deter China and …
https://www.foreignaffairs.com › united-states › robert…
Sep 29, 2023 — A world without reliable U.S. leadership would be a world of authoritarian predators, with all other countries potential prey. If America is …
Strong Deterrence Enables U.S. to Ensure Global Rules …
U.S. Department of Defense (.gov)
https://www.defense.gov › News › Article › Article › s…
Dec 3, 2022 — “American airpower helps deter conflict every day, from joint exercises with our Indo-Pacific partners, to aerial drills with our allies to …
What Washington Gets Wrong About Deterrence
https://warontherocks.com › 2023/05 › what-washingt…
May 22, 2023 — While deterrence is not entirely divorced from the tangible things like the deployment of platforms and stockpiles of munitions, perceptions …
Deterrence Ensures Great Power Competition Doesn’t …
U.S. Department of Defense (.gov)
https://www.defense.gov › News › Article › Article
Dec 7, 2021 — “Some 26,000 Americans died from hitting the beaches at Normandy, to the liberation of Paris. That was just one campaign.” “Great power war is …
‘Free world defense’ strategy strikes balance between U.S. …
https://www.legion.org › landingzone › ‘free-world-…
Oct 5, 2023 — More partners A “free world defense” strategy would, by definition, enlist the entire free world to deter the axis of autocracy. America cannot …
The urgent imperative to maintain NATO’s nuclear deterrence
https://www.nato.int › review › articles › 2023/09/29
Sep 29, 2023 — Providing a robust range of response options to restore deterrence by convincing Russian leadership they have direly miscalculated, that further …
U.S. Deterrence in Taiwan Is Failing
https://foreignpolicy.com › 2023/09/08 › us-military-de…
Sep 8, 2023 — “Deterrence by punishment” convinces an enemy not to attack by persuading him that the effort—even if successful—will incur an exorbitant price.
The Dangers of Relying on Conventional Forces for Nuclear …
https://www.airuniversity.af.edu › V-Bradley
by J Bradley · Cited by 8 — Dan Gouré, “How Barack Obama’s Vision of a Nuclear-Free World Weakens America’s Security: Russia, Deterrence, and Missile Defense,” Heritage Foundation, 10 …
12 pages
What Will It Take to Deter the United States? – USAWC Press
https://press.armywarcollege.edu › viewcontent
by RK Betts · 1995 · Cited by 38 — Few adversaries are likely to risk a catastrophic escalation just to deter US economic pressure. Trade sanctions are not as serious a challenge …
The Paradox of Power: Sino-American Strategic Restraint in …
https://ndupress.ndu.edu › Documents › Books
by C Gompert · Cited by 102 — that nuclear deterrence is not taught in the international relations and security lectures that senior party members receive. 29 Information Office of the …
How effective is America’s deterrence?
https://www.defensenews.com › opinion › 2021/01/27
Jan 27, 2021 — Deterrence is not a static policy that can be instituted and remain effective; it needs to be maintained and updated periodically to cope …
U.S. Geopolitics and Nuclear Deterrence in the Era of Great …
https://academic.oup.com › psq › article
by P Rudolf · 2021 · Cited by 2 — In the U.S. security policy discourse, strategic competitions with a rising China and a resurgent Russia have moved into the spotlight. The United States, which …
https://www.whitehouse.gov › 2022/10 › Bide…
Oct 12, 2022 — This American project will never be complete—democracy is always a work in progress—but that will not stop us from defending our values and …
The National Security Strategy of the United States …
George W. Bush White House Archives (.gov)
https://georgewbush-whitehouse.archives.gov › nssall
For freedom to thrive, accountability must be expected and required. We are also guided by the conviction that no nation can build a safer, better world alone.
https://www.economist.com › 2014/05/01 › the-decli…
May 1, 2014 — America is no longer as alarming to its foes or reassuring to its friends | United States.